European Association
of Environmental and Resource Economists
EAERE President Correspondence
N. 9 - Final Commentary
Colleagues,
This is my final Commentary as President.
It is easy to be portentous about the significance of ones term of office.
Stephen Leacock put the case for his contribution as follows: When
I state that my lectures were followed almost immediately by the Union
of South Africa, the banana riots in Trinidad and the Turco-Italian
war, I think the reader can form some opinion of their importance.
My two-year tenure as President of EAERE has taken place in interesting
and disturbing times, with continuing and escalating conflicts around
the world, suicide bombings and associated mayhem and murder, riots
in France, all followed by a rise in police powers and erosion of rights
for the individual, and a series of intense and very destructive weather-related
events. But association is not causation.
Cardinal John Henry Newman was the founding President of my university
- UCD Dublin. In Lead Kindly Light he sets out his modest ethos, and
this also informs my view of how to make progress: I do not ask to
see the distant scene; one step enough for me.
In advocating small steps, the following shaped my thinking, and contributed
also to a sense of urgency:
The opportunity costs of time are increasing for most of us. Even minor
academic stars today are like modern Opera singers - their talents may
be modest enough, but the world is their stage, and time is their most
precious resource. This means that, to keep attracting interest and
engagement from people of capacity, EAERE has to keep improving what
it does and how it does it.
Given that time is so scarce, it is easy to draw a conclusion that all
business should be conducted electronically. In Ireland, most of us
are only one generation away from the land and the cattle market, where
face-to-face contact, the handshake and the shared conviviality of a
drink together have been since early Celtic times pre-requisites for
successful business and social cohesion. I believe also in Woody Allen's
dictum that '80 per cent of success is showing up.' And so your
Council members showed up and met together from time to time to share
ideas and move our agenda forward, in addition, of course to interacting
electronically.
You can't get productively involved until you know what's going on.
Communication is the first pre-requisite for commitment and action.
And so we re-energised the Newsletter under Katrin Millock's leadership,
I provided an occasional commentary, and our Secretary General Monica
Eberle re-invented our web site as an effective voice, and kept in touch
with you on administrative and managerial issues.
Most voluntary organisations eventually fail. This is not because what
they do is not worth doing. It is because they fail to administer effectively,
efficiently and persistently their governance, finances, their membership,
their ever-increasing legal obligations, their fund raising, their activities
and developments. The last Council made the decision to create a permanent
Secretariat in FEEM, and this has provided all of these qualities that
are so essential to sustainable organisational development. One example:
it allowed us to apply successfully in 2005 to the European Commission
for medium term (4 year) funding to support the Summer School; the latter
is one of our adornments, and to have secured funding for a number of
years is a great relief financially, and a great achievement in supporting
the continued development of our field.
Centuries ago in Italy, the motto of an institution of learning known
as the Accademia del Cimento, was 'provando e riprovando' - reject
that which cannot be maintained in the light of reason and experience.
We must have good theory, but evidence is a necessary complement if
theory is to develop productively, and if our profession is to have
credibility with those who must make difficult decisions. And so we
encouraged the submission of evidence-based papers at our annual meeting
in Bremen to give this strand of our profession more profile and status.
We have been inordinately shy in recognising outstanding achievement
amongst our peers. And so we inaugurated the Outstanding Achievement
Awards, which in Bremen were awarded to giants of our field - Jos Delbeke,
Karl-Göran Mäler, and David Pearce. These recognitions were
joyful occasions, made poignant and special now by the subsequent death
of David Pearce. He has gone, but his benign intellectual and personal
shadow will continue to provide many with continuing inspiration and
support. Peter Bohm is another inspirational colleague who died in 2005
and leaves a space in our personal and professional lives that is very
difficult to fill.
When we look ahead, we can see a Europe that faces great challenges.
In many EU countries, rules and cultural reflexes still favour incumbents.
Ireland is an interesting counter example. Since May 2004, about 100,000
Polish citizens have moved to Ireland, adding 2.5 per cent to the total
resident population; a Polish newspaper is on the Newsstands, and a
Polish radio station is about to start transmitting. These new entrants
have already added tremendously to the economic and social life of the
country, and are part of the explanation why the economy is expected
to grow by about 5 per cent in 2005. Making a country economically and
socially congenial to immigrants of quality is not a friction free process,
and is helped in the Irish case by the fact that there is very little
long-term unemployment. But is also clear that making it easy for new
entrants has great benefits for all, and that 'incumbent bias' can be
a very expensive and destructive asymmetry in social organisation.
The point is not to boast of the Irish success - we have had our own
form of self inflicted economic nightmare, and no doubt will have again
- but to argue that effective management of the macro economy is the
essential pre-requisite for a successful continent and environment.
With the introduction of the European Union emissions trading scheme
we have set out on an exciting journey that can show the way forward
in addressing climate change. But its credibility and therefore its
attractiveness to others will be weakened if Europe as a whole continues
to flounder economically.
Günter Grass has told us that 'the job of the citizen is to
keep his mouth open.' We need to act on his admonition in regard
to shaping the discourses on our European economy, and how important
it is that considerations of environment be integrated in this debate.
A great Secretary General can make a President and Council look good
by keeping all administrative matters in good order, by ensuring that
alerts about upcoming events and challenges are timely and effective,
by simultaneously identifying solutions to problems as they emerge,
by being flexible in meeting crises, and by adding an imaginative impulse
to the agenda and deliberations of Council. Monica Eberle has been a
great Secretary General, and we are very grateful to her. I also thank:
deputy President Nick Hanley and Council members for their support,
endeavour and patience; Sandor Kerekes and Wolfgang Pfaffenberger who
took the risks and delivered excellence in our annual conferences in
Budapest and Bremen respectively; Michael Rauscher, who has helped on
your behalf shape the upcoming World Congress in Kyoto in July 06; the
editor of our journal, Ian Bateman, and Kerry Turner and their team
for keeping this crucial strand of our intellectual life strong and
growing; Katrin Millock who has revived this Newsletter to great effect;
you our members who have contributed in numberless ways make us what
we are, a vibrant, successful and enjoyable organisation.
Our field of environmental and resource economics can be likened to
the stars of the sky, whose beauty increases when they are studied for
a long time, and new stars are discovered. I would like finally to wish
incoming President Tasos Xepapadeas and his incoming Council team the
very best as they continue our reach for the stars.