European Association
of Environmental and Resource Economists
EAERE President Correspondence
N. 5 - December 2004 - On being
15, and celebrating excellence
Colleagues,
Fifteen is an awkward, difficult age. Adolescence struggles into early
adulthood. Acne is omnipresent. Hormones go ballistic, and sex is a
24-hour preoccupation. We become convinced that we must have been adopted
at an early age; it is not conceivable that the pathetic ineptitudes
who call themselves our parents and try to prevent us from fulfilment
could possibly be related to us. Our genetic parents are somewhere else
- beautiful, sophisticated, classy, rich, tolerant, indulgent. Narcissism,
sentimentality and garrulous insecurity all strive to co-exist in a
body that changes daily, and with a spirit that moves in emotional waves
of highs and lows of erratic and sometimes alarming intensity. And the
struggle is joined for an identity and personality that is comfortable,
that provides enough stability to allow us to grow intellectually and
emotionally. It is the point where idealism - the sense that fulfilment
means more that maximising our own pecuniary self-interest - takes hold;
we begin to sense that market failure is a reality, that adjustments
in how we organise our lives may be necessary if the individual interest
and the societal interest are to coincide.
EAERE will be 15 years old next year. Its founding members were:
Henk Folmer, Netherlands
Karl-Göran Mäler, Sweden
Juan Martinez-Alier, Spain
Ignazio Musu, Italy
David Pearce, UK
Rüdiger Pethig, Germany
Domenico Siniscalco, Italy
They stated their aspirations for our association as follows:
- Contribute to the development and application of environmental economics
as a science in Europe;
- Improve communication and contacts between researchers, teachers and
students in environmental economics in the different European countries;
- Develop and encourage cooperation between teaching institutions of
university level and research institutions in Europe.
Organisations are not people - we don't have acne, and we're not collectively
obsessed by sex. But we do share some traits. We strive to find our
place in the world, to keep the wider public interest in view, to keep
faith with the vision identified by our founders. To give concrete expression
to our first objective - contribute to the development and application
of environmental economics in Europe - we decided this coming year to
recognise a small number of individuals who over a lifetime have made
exceptional contributions to the development of our field, and to the
application of environmental economics in Europe. A large number of
nominations were received from our membership, from which a few were
unanimously chosen for recognition by the Council.
As regards development of our field, we confined the choice to those
who had already, or would shortly, reach the 'official' retirement age
from their main institution, and Karl-Göran Mäler and
David Pearce were selected. This is not the place to dwell on
their manifold contributions, but I will provide a few personal reflections.
Karl-Göran has written what many regard as the definitive
book in our field, and he has consistently provided the intellectual
ballast to the subject of environmental economics that ensured it was
taken seriously by the economics mainstream. It is difficult to overstate
the importance of such intellectual accreditation. As Director of the
Beijer Institute, he has encouraged the integration of ecology and economics,
an intellectual stretch that many have thought about, a few have tried
to bridge, but with limited success. His consistent leadership in this
area provides this interface with a status, a precedent and a template
that will yield great intellectual and practical dividends. At a personal
level, his combination of intellectual rigour, humour and complete unpretentiousness
as to rank or position make him great company, notwithstanding his unaccountable
(to Irish sensibilities at least) culinary enthusiasm for putrid herring
('surströmming').
Integration of economy and environment is a consistent thread in David
Pearce's work - the idea that environment can and should be given
'parity of esteem' in managing the macro and the micro economy is at
the heart of his contribution. He not only shows how it can be done,
but gets involved in making it happen; his engagement with the UK government,
the OECD, the World Bank, UN, European Commission and many others have
all been directed at giving substance in the policy arena to our ideas.
His books have numerous printings, and are translated into many languages;
both scholars and those in the policy process in China, France, Greece,
Italy, Japan, Korea, Malaysia, Slovakia and Vietnam can read his work
in their own language. His 'Blueprint for a Green Economy' (with Anil
Markandya and Ed Barbier) shows that clarity, brevity and simplicity
can be a powerful combination in shaping the terms and substance of
the policy debate. The graduates of the Masters degree in environmental
economics at UCL has of course comprised the '5th column' that has spread
the Gospel of environmental economics throughout the world.
As regards outstanding achievement in the implementation of economics
ideas, Jos Delbeke is our unanimous nominee. Henk Folmer and
I first encountered Jos when we served together on a European Commission
task force focused on understanding the relationship between the European
Single Market and the environment. His ability to organise, to draw
coherence from chaos and his dedication to embedding economics ideas
in the decision-making system were apparent then. As he successfully
progressed up the Commission's slippery career pole, a consistent strand
of his work has been to inject economics ideas into the environmental
policy arena. It's not easy. Camus observed that 'we're all special
cases.' And most of the special interest constituencies that attempt
to shape EU policy don't see the economic argument as central, and many
regard it as inimical to their interest. And so keeping a regard for
benefits and costs, for mobilising markets to protect the environment
rather than the converse, for making economic efficiency and integration
of environment and economy central rather than incidental, involves
in the first instance fighting the case with the other services of the
Commission, then getting the Member States and the European Parliament
to buy into the idea, creating coalitions of interest to move an agenda
forward in ways that are consistent with economic principles. We need
his unique talents, because Europe faces a huge challenge in competing
in the global economy, and so the environment also faces a challenge,
since many see the choice as a trade-off - less conservation means more
competitiveness. Achieving mutuality of interest requires advocacy of
a high order from the Commission
Karl-Göran Mäler, David Pearce and Jos Delbeke will join
us at our annual
conference in Bremen, June 23-26, 2005 to celebrate their achievement.
You are encouraged to send a short paragraph to Monica (monica.eberle@feem.it)
recounting any positive professional or personal experience, interactions,
use of publications etc. associated with one or more of these individuals.
Get these to Monica by January 15, 2005. Katrin Millock (Newsletter
editor) will use a selection to include in our next Newsletter (due
out January 24, 2005) and we'll put them all on our web site.
On behalf of your Council, I wish you all a very enjoyable, safe and
relaxed Christmas, and may 2005 be good to us all.
Frank J. Convery EAERE President
Favourite Quote: 'This fictional account of the day-to-day life of an English game
keeper is still of considerable interest to outdoor minded readers,
as it contains many passages on pheasant raising, the apprehending of
poachers, ways to control vermin, and other chores and duties of the
professional game keeper. Unfortunately, one is obliged to wade through
many pages of extraneous material in order to discover and saviour these
sidelights on the management of a Midlands shooting estate, and in this
reviewer's opinion, this book cannot take the place of JH Miller's Practical
Gamekeeping.' Review of Lady Chatterly's Lover in Field and Stream